The region R is bounded by the graph of f(x)=2x(2-x) and the x-axis. Which is greater, the volume of the solid generated when R is revolved about the line y=2 or the volume of the solid generated when R is revolved about the line y=0?

1 Answer
Apr 13, 2018

The solid from revolving around the #x#-axis is greater

Explanation:

.

#R# is the area bounded by:

#y=2x(2-x)# and #y=0# (#x#-axis).

#2x(2-x)=0, :. x=0 and 2#

This is a parabola that opens down and crosses the #x#-axis at #x=0 and 2#

If this area is revolved about the #x#-axis the resulting solid will look like the following figure:

enter image source here

If we cut a vertical slice through the solid with a thickness #=dx# we will have a circular disc whose radius is #y=2x(2-x)#.

The area of this circular disc is:

#A=pir^2=pi[2x(2-x)]^2=pi[4x^2(x^2-4x+4)]#

#A=pi(4x^4-16x^3+16x^2)#

Then the volume of this disc would br:

#V_("disc")=pi(4x^4-16x^3+16x^2)dx#

Now, imagine that the thickness #dx# is infinitely small and there are infinite number of discs with varying radii between #x=0 and 2#.

If we take the integral of the area of this disc and evaluate it from #0 to 2# we will get the volume of the solid.

#V_("Solid")=int_0^2pi(4x^4-16x^3+16x^2)dx#

#V_("Solid")=pi(4/5x^5-4x^4+16/3x^3)_0^2=pi(4/5(32)-4(16)+16/3(8))=pi(128/5-64+128/3)=pi(384-960+640)/15=64/15pi#

If the area between the parabola and the #x#-axis is revolved around the line #y=2# the solid generated will look like the following figure:

enter image source here

If we cut a vertical slice through this solid with a thickness of #dx# we will have a circular washer (a disc with a hole in the middle). The outer radius of this washer is #r_2=2# and the inner radius of the washer is #r_1=y=2x(2-x)#.

We can calculate the area of the washer by subtracting the area of the inner circle from the area of the outer circle:

#A_("Washer")=pir_2^2-pir_1^2=pi(r_2^2-r_1^2)=pi[4-(2x(2-x))^2]#

#A_("Washer")=pi(-4x^4+16x^3-16x^2+4)#

The volume of the washer is:

#V_("Washer")=pi(-4x^4+16x^3-16x^2+4)dx#

Now, imagine that the thickness of the washer #dx# is infinitely small and there are infinite number of washers between #x=0 and 2#. If we add the volumes of these washers together we will have the volume of the solid.

To do this, we will take the integral of the area function:

#V_("Solid")=int_0^2pi(-4x^4+16x^3-16x^2+4)dx#

#V_("Solid")=pi(-4/5x^5+4x^4-16/3x^3+4x)_0^2#

#V_("Solid")=pi(-4/5(32)+4(16)-16/3(8)+4(2))#

#V_("Solid")=pi(-128/5+64-128/3+8)#

#V_("Solid")=pi(-384+960-640+120)/15#

#V_("Solid")=56/15pi#

Therefore, the solid from revolving around the #x#-axis is greater