Why isn't the notation for the second derivative #dy^2/dx#?

3 Answers
Nov 18, 2017

See below.

Explanation:

Probably because #(dy^2)/dx# would be read as the derivative of #y^2# in respect of #x#.

The general notation #(d^2y)/dx^2# could be misconstrued as the derivative in respect of #x^2#, but then you can find lots of flaws in mathematical notations, but we just have to accept that this is how they have been defined.

Nov 18, 2017

Please see below.

Explanation:

For #f(x)# a function of #x#, we can denote the derivative in several ways.

On family of notations uses a "differential operator".
This is a notation that tells us "take the derivative".

For example #D_x(5x^2+3)# means "The derivative, with respect to #x#, of the function #f(x)=5x^2+3#. SO #D_x(5x^2+3) = 10x#.

#d/dx# is another notation for "the derivative with respect to #x# of . . . #

So #d/dx(5x^2+3)# means the same thing as #D_x(5x^2+3)#.

To take the second derivative, we take the derivative twice:

#D_x(D_x(5x^2+3))# is written #D_x^2(5x^2+3)#

#d/dx(d/dx(5x^2+3))# could, perhaps, be written #(d/dx)^2(5x^2+3)#, but the standard notation is #d^2/dx^2(5x^2+3)#.

If we let #y = 5x^2+3#, then these examples look like:

First derivative: #D_x(y)# and #d/dx(y)# which is also written #dy/dx#.

Second derivative: #D_x^2(y)# and #d^2/dx^2(y)# which is also written #(d^2y)/dx^2#.

In this notation, we do not think of #dx# as #d# times #x#

Instead, we are thinking of #dx# as a single quantity. That is why we do NOT write #d^2/(dx)^2(y)#

Additional Note

I would interpret #dy^2/dx# as #d/dx(y^2)#. Using the chain rule, I would evaluate to get #d/dx(y^2) = 2y * dy/dx#.

Using #y=5x^2+3# again, we have #d/dx(5x^2+3)^2 = 2(5x^2+3)*5 = 10(5x^2+3)#

Note 2

#(dy/dx)^2# means the square of the derivative of #y#.
Using #y=5x^2+3# again, we have

#(dy/dx)^2 = (10x)^2 = 100x^2#.

This kind of expression can come up if using implicit differentiation to find 2nd or higher derivatives. (If we don't pause to solve for #dy/dx# before our second differentiation.)

Nov 18, 2017

See below.

Explanation:

#d/(dx)(dy/dx) = (d^2y)/(dx^2)#
#d/(dx)(d/dx)y = (d^2)/(dx^2)y = (d^2y)/(dx^2)#