Prove that (cosxcotx)/(1 - sinx) - 1 = cscxcosxcotx1sinx1=cscx?

2 Answers
May 12, 2016

We start with:

color(green)((cosxcotx)/(1-sinx) - 1 stackrel(?)(=) cscx).cosxcotx1sinx1?=cscx.

First, recall cotx = cosx/sinxcotx=cosxsinx (since cotx = 1/tanxcotx=1tanx and tanx = sinx/cosxtanx=sinxcosx). That gives you:

(cosx*cosx/sinx)/(1-sinx) - 1 = cscxcosxcosxsinx1sinx1=cscx

(cos^2x/sinx)/(1-sinx) - 1 = cscxcos2xsinx1sinx1=cscx

On the fraction you can move the middle sinxsinx into the denominator.

cos^2x/(sinx(1-sinx)) - 1 = cscxcos2xsinx(1sinx)1=cscx

Now, when you have a 11, that gives you a lot of freedom. You can choose to have it be equal to any ratio you want, as long as it cancels out to be 11. So choose 1 = (sinx(1-sinx))/(sinx(1-sinx))1=sinx(1sinx)sinx(1sinx) to get:

cos^2x/(sinx(1-sinx)) - (sinx(1-sinx))/(sinx(1-sinx)) = cscxcos2xsinx(1sinx)sinx(1sinx)sinx(1sinx)=cscx

Distribute the numerator and combine into one fraction:

(-sinx + cos^2x + sin^2x)/(sinx(1-sinx)) = cscxsinx+cos2x+sin2xsinx(1sinx)=cscx

Then recall sin^2x + cos^2x = 1sin2x+cos2x=1 to cancel out the 1-sinx1sinx.

cancel(1 - sinx)/(sinxcancel((1-sinx))) = cscx

1/sinx = cscx

color(blue)(cscx = cscx)

May 12, 2016

It is a bit long but...

Explanation:

You can try changing all in sin and cos as:
cot(x)=cos(x)/sin(x)
csc(x)=1/sin(x)
Your identity becomes:

(cos(x)*cos(x)/sin(x))/(1-sin(x))-1=1/sin(x)
we use (1-sin(x))(sin(x)) as common denominator and write rearranging:
(cos^2(x)-sin(x)(1-sin(x)))/cancel((1-sin(x))(sin(x)))=(1-sin(x))/cancel((1-sin(x))(sin(x)))

and:
cos^2(x)-sin(x)(1-sin(x))=1-sin(x)
cos^2(x)-sin(x)+sin^2(x)=1-sin(x)
but:
cos^2(x)+sin^2(x)=1
so we get:
1-sin(x)=1-sin(x) which is true.