Circle A has a center at #(6 ,5 )# and an area of #6 pi#. Circle B has a center at #(12 ,7 )# and an area of #48 pi#. Do the circles overlap?

1 Answer
May 10, 2018

Since

#(12-6)^2+(7-5)^2=40 quad # and

#4(6)(48) - (40 - 6 - 48)^2 = 956 > 0 #

we can make a real triangle with squared sides 48, 6 and 40, so these circles intersect.

Explanation:

Why the gratuitous #pi#?

The area is #A =pi r^2# so #r^2=A/pi.# So the first circle has a radius #r_1=\sqrt{6}# and the second #r_2=sqrt{48}=4 sqrt{3}#.

The centers are #sqrt{(12-6)^2+(7-5)^2}= sqrt{40} = 2 sqrt{10}# apart.

So the circles overlap if #sqrt{6} + 4 sqrt{3} ge 2 sqrt{10} #.

That's so ugly that you'd be forgiven for reaching for the calculator. But it's really not necessary. Let's take a detour and look how this is done using Rational Trigonometry. There we're only concerned with the squared lengths, called quadrances.

Let's say we want to test if three quadrances #A,B,C# are the quadrances between three collinear points, i.e. #sqrt{A}=sqrt{B}+sqrt{C}# or #sqrt{B}=sqrt{A}+sqrt{C},# or #sqrt{C}=sqrt{A}+sqrt{B}#. We'll write it as

# pm sqrt{C} = pm sqrt{A} pm sqrt{B}#

Squaring,

#C = A + B \pm 2 sqrt{AB}#

#C - A-B = pm 2 sqrt{AB}#

Squaring again,

#(C-A-B)^2 = 4AB #

#0 = 4AB - (C-A-B)^2 #

It turns out

#mathcal{A} = 4AB - (C-A-B)^2 #

is a discriminant for triangles. We just showed if #mathcal{A} =0# that means we have a degenerate triangle, formed from three collinear points. If #mathcal{A} > 0# then we have a real triangle, each side less than the sum of the other two. If #mathcal{A}<0# we don't have sides that satisfies the triangle inequality, and we sometimes call this an imaginary triangle.

Let's turn back to our question armed with our new triangle discriminant #mathcal{A}#. If the circles intersect we we can make a triangle of the two centers and an intersection, so the sides will have lengths #r_1#, #r_2#, and the distance between the centers #(6,5)# and #(12,7)#. We have

# A = r_1^2 = 6#

#B = r_2^2 = 48 #

#C= (12-6)^2+(7-5)^2=40#

#mathcal{A} = 4AB - (C-A-B)^2 = 4(6)(48) - (40 - 6 - 48)^2 = 956 #

#mathcal{A} > 0# so we have a real triangle, i.e overlapping circles.

Oh yeah, for any triangle #mathcal{A} = 16 (text{area})^2 .#

Check: Alpha

enter image source here