Why is the oxidation of #Mn^(2+)# in ACIDIC media represented differently to the oxidation of #Mn^(2+)# in an ALKALINE medium? What do we mean by #H^+# or #H_3O^+#?

1 Answer
anor277
Mar 24, 2017

Because chemistry follows experiment...........

Explanation:

#H^+# is very much a conceptual particle. When we write #H^+# in a reaction we mean the hydronium ion, #H_3O^+#, which AGAIN is a conceptual species. The actual species is (probably) a cluster of 3-4 water molecules, with an extra proton to give #H_7O_3^+#, or #H_9O_4^+#. The clusters exchange the proton between themselves. We write #H^+# or #H_3O^+# for convenience.

When we write a redox equation, of course we balance mass and charge, and the use of #H^+# or #H_3O^+# is a means to this end. It happens that in ACIDIC medium, #Mn^(2+)#, may be oxidized to #MnO_4^(-)#:

#Mn^(2+) +4H_2O rarr MnO_4^(-) + 8H^(+) + 5e^-#

In alkaline media, #Mn^(2+)# may be oxidized to #"manganate ion"#, #MnO_4^(2-)#, which is #Mn(VI+)#:

#Mn^(2+) +8HO^(-) rarr MnO_4^(2-) + 4H_2O + 4e^-#

#"Manganates"# give green salts.

Mass and charge are balanced (I think) as required. Note that this representation follows the actual experiment, not vice versa.

If there is a further issue or query, fire away.

Related questions
See all questions in Redox Reactions
Impact of this question
1949 views around the world
You can reuse this answer
Creative Commons License