How would you prove that cuprous oxide is not an element?

1 Answer
Truong-Son N.
Jun 8, 2017

By inspection?

Cuprous = copper cation with lower oxidation state, from the Latin, "cuprum"
oxide = #"O"^(2-)# anion

Cuprous oxide uses the old naming scheme, wherein "ous" indicates the lower oxidation state of copper. So, this is #"Cu"_2"O"# (rather than #"CuO"#, cupric oxide).

But even if you didn't know that, that doesn't matter, because we know it contains two different elements. Copper has an atomic number not equal to #8#.

By definition, #"Cu"_2"O"# must therefore be a compound. An element must have a single identity and thus contain atom(s) with one consistent atomic number.

(that's why we specify that #"H"_2#, #"O"_2#, #"F"_2#, #"Br"_2#, #"I"_2#, #"N"_2#, and #"Cl"_2# are "diatomic elements", as opposed to simply "elements".)

Related questions
See all questions in Review of Elements and Compounds
Impact of this question
3437 views around the world
You can reuse this answer
Creative Commons License