An electron is excited from the n=1 ground state to the n=3 state in a hydrogen atom. Does it take more energy to ionize (completely remove) the electron from n=3 than from the ground state?

1 Answer
anor277
Mar 11, 2017

Well, if you are climbing a flight of stairs..........

Explanation:

.........does it take you more energy to climb from the bottom of the stairs, than from 3 steps up the flight of stairs? Quite clearly it does.

When we ionize an electron, essentially we raise it from #n=1# to #n=oo#; now clearly this is going to be endothermic:

#"Atom, (n=1),"+Delta_1 rarr "Atom"^+(n=oo) + e^-#

But when we raise the electron from #n=1# to #n=3#, then clearly this also will be endothermic:

#"Atom, (n=1),"+Delta_2 rarr "Atom"^+(n=3)+ e^-#

#"Atom, (n=3),"+Delta_3 rarr "Atom"^+(n=oo) + e^-#

Clearly, #Delta_2+Delta_3=Delta_1# by considerations of conservation of energy. And thus, necessarily, #Delta_1>Delta_3# (and the difference is #Delta_2#). Are you happy with this treatment?

Related questions
See all questions in Excited States and Ground States
Impact of this question
5113 views around the world
You can reuse this answer
Creative Commons License